St. Augustine Homes for Sale With Guest House: What to Know Before You Buy

A separate living space on the same lot can be a big win, whether it is for visiting family, a parent who wants to live close by, a home office or a studio. If you are searching for St. Augustine homes for sale with guest house space, you will find a mix of detached cottages, garage apartments, in-law suites and older homes with a converted outbuilding. The key is knowing what you are actually buying and how you are allowed to use it. Here is what to look for.

Buying a St. Augustine Home With a Guest House: Quick Answer

Guest houses in the St. Augustine area range from detached cottages to apartments over a garage to attached in-law suites. Before you buy, confirm the space was permitted, check the zoning and any HOA rules, and ask how it may be used. In unincorporated St. Johns County, the county’s accessory family unit rules generally limit a second living unit to family members of the owner, require the owner to live in the main home, and do not allow it to be rented or sold separately. City of St. Augustine, St. Augustine Beach and HOA rules can differ, so verify current rules for the specific property before you count on rental income.

Types of Guest Houses You Will See

  • Detached cottage or casita. A separate small building with its own entry, often with a bedroom, bath and kitchenette.
  • Garage apartment. Living space above or beside a detached garage. Common in older parts of town.
  • In-law suite. An attached wing with its own bedroom, bath and sometimes a separate entrance and kitchenette. Many newer St. Johns County builders offer multigenerational floor plans.
  • Converted outbuilding. A workshop, pool house or carriage house that a past owner finished out. These need the most homework.

What to Check on St. Augustine Homes for Sale With Guest House Space

Permits. Ask the seller for permits and final inspections for the guest house, and look up the property’s permit history with the city or county. An unpermitted conversion can affect insurance, appraisal, financing and resale.

Zoning and use rules. Whether a second unit can be rented long term, used as a short-term rental or only lived in by family depends on where the property is. Unincorporated St. Johns County, the City of St. Augustine and the City of St. Augustine Beach each have their own codes, and HOAs can add more restrictions. Call the planning and zoning office for the address, and read the HOA documents if there is an association.

Historic district review. In the City of St. Augustine’s historic districts, exterior changes, including adding or altering an outbuilding, generally go through the city’s architectural review process. Factor that in if you plan to expand.

Utilities. Find out whether the guest house shares water, sewer or septic and electric service with the main home, and whether the septic system is sized for both.

Flood zone and elevation. A detached building may sit at a different elevation than the main house. Check the flood zone and get insurance quotes that cover both structures.

Appraisal and financing. Lenders and appraisers look at whether the guest house is legal and typical for the area. Talk to your lender early if you are hoping to count any rental income.

Where to Look

Guest houses show up most often on larger lots and in established neighborhoods, but they can pop up almost anywhere. Areas with bigger parcels, older homes near downtown and the beaches, and newer communities with multigenerational floor plans are all worth a look. Browse our St. Augustine homes for sale with guest house options by community, or see homes for sale in Nocatee to the north. If you also want to avoid association rules, read our guide to St. Augustine homes for sale with no HOA.

St. Augustine Guest House Homes: FAQ

Can I rent out a guest house in St. Augustine?

It depends on the location, zoning and any HOA. In unincorporated St. Johns County, accessory family units are generally limited to family members and cannot be rented. Other rules may apply inside city limits. Always verify with the local planning office before you buy.

Does a guest house add value?

A permitted, well-built guest house can appeal to many buyers. Tanya can pull recent comparable sales so you can see how similar homes have sold.

Can I add a guest house after I buy?

Sometimes. Lot size, setbacks, zoning, HOA approval, flood zone and historic review all play a part. Check before you count on it.

Is an in-law suite the same as a guest house?

Not exactly. An in-law suite is usually attached to the main home, while a guest house is a separate building. Rules can treat them differently.

Find a Guest House Home With Tanya

Tanya Cosmini of Realty ONE Group Elevate holds the CLHMS, ABR and MRP designations and has 83 sales and $41.8M in volume with a 5.0-star rating from 22 reviews on Homes.com. Tell her how you plan to use the extra space and she will send you homes that fit.

Call or Text (904) 439-9842 Get Guest House Listings

Information is general and believed reliable but not guaranteed. Zoning, permitting, rental and HOA rules change and vary by property; confirm with the City of St. Augustine, the City of St. Augustine Beach or St. Johns County, the HOA, and qualified inspectors before you buy. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Get St. Augustine Guest House Listings

Tell Tanya your budget, the areas you like and how you plan to use the guest space.

How Can We Help You?

We would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and we will get in touch with you shortly.

    (check all that apply)
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Our Family of Companies

  • Realty ONE Group Elevate, a full-service real estate brokerage with offices in Jacksonville and St. Augustine
  • Title Company of Florida, title insurance, escrow, and closings statewide, with a $299 settlement fee for veterans, active duty military and first responders
  • Rental Property Partners, property management in Jacksonville, St. Augustine, and Ponte Vedra

Affiliated business disclosure: Realty ONE Group Elevate is owned by Tanya Cosmini. Title Company of Florida is owned by her husband, Sam Gorniak, and Rental Property Partners is owned within the same family. Because of these family relationships, the owners may benefit when you use more than one of these companies. You are not required to use any of them and are free to choose other providers.

Connect With Us!

If you're looking to buy or sell a property connect with us today!

How Can We Help You?

We would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and we will get in touch with you shortly.

    (check all that apply)
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *