Choosing a Realtor in St. Augustine is a big decision, and many buyers and sellers look at DJ and Lindsey Real Estate St. Augustine alongside other local agents. This guide is a fair side-by-side look at DJ and Lindsey Real Estate St. Augustine and Tanya Cosmini of Realty ONE Group Elevate, using facts each company publishes, plus the questions that help you pick the right agent for your situation.
DJ and Lindsey Real Estate St. Augustine vs. Tanya Cosmini: Quick Answer
DJ & Lindsey Real Estate is a large, multi-office Florida brokerage founded in 2013 with an office in St. Augustine. Tanya Cosmini is the Broker/Owner of Realty ONE Group Elevate, a Jacksonville and St. Augustine brokerage, and works directly with her clients. Both are real options, and the right choice depends on whether you want a big-team platform or a hands-on owner-led relationship. Interview at least two agents, and compare who will actually handle your transaction.
DJ and Lindsey Real Estate St. Augustine vs. Tanya Cosmini: At a Glance
| DJ & Lindsey Real Estate | Tanya Cosmini, Realty ONE Group Elevate | |
|---|---|---|
| Leadership | Co-founders DJ and Lindsey DellaSala (founded 2013, per the company) | Tanya Cosmini, Broker/Owner |
| Offices | St. Augustine, Jacksonville, Palm Beach Gardens and Winter Park, among others listed on its website | Jacksonville and St. Augustine |
| Company-reported track record | More than $5B in sales volume, 10,000+ homes sold, 5,000+ five-star reviews (no time period stated) | 500+ homes and $400M+ in Northeast Florida real estate (career total, as stated on this site) |
| Designations | Varies by agent; check each agent’s profile | CLHMS, ABR and MRP |
Figures are company-reported and have not been independently verified. DJ & Lindsey details come from its public website as read on November 21, 2026. DJ & Lindsey Real Estate is a separate company with no affiliation to Tanya Cosmini or Realty ONE Group Elevate.
Top 3 Reasons to Choose Tanya Cosmini
1. You work directly with the Broker/Owner. Tanya Cosmini owns Realty ONE Group Elevate and personally guides her clients, so the person who answers your call is the person responsible for your result. Whichever agent you choose, ask who will actually write your offer, answer your calls and attend your inspection.
2. Credentials that match what buyers and sellers need. Tanya holds the Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS), Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR) and Military Relocation Professional (MRP) designations. Luxury listings can be marketed through ONE LUXE, Realty ONE Group’s luxury program, and military families get an agent trained in relocation. See more about Tanya.
3. Deep local coverage and early access. This site has dedicated guides for dozens of St. Augustine, Nocatee, Ponte Vedra and Jacksonville communities, from Palencia to Nocatee and Jacksonville. Clients can also join the free Private & Coming Soon List to hear about homes early.
Where DJ & Lindsey Real Estate Is Strong
To be fair, DJ & Lindsey is a large brokerage with several offices, an in-house team structure and a big online presence, and it reports a high volume of sales and reviews. If you want a large organization with many agents and a marketing platform behind them, that is a legitimate reason to consider them. Larger firms and owner-led firms simply work differently, so choose the one that fits how you like to be served.
How to Choose a St. Augustine Real Estate Agent
- Ask who you will work with day to day. The person you meet at the listing presentation should be the person who handles your sale.
- Ask for recent results in your neighborhood. St. Augustine, Anastasia Island, Nocatee and Ponte Vedra each behave differently.
- Compare marketing plans in writing. Photography, video, pricing strategy and how the home reaches buyers.
- Read the agreement. Since August 2024, buyers typically sign a written agreement with their agent that spells out how the agent is paid. Compensation is negotiable.
- Check reviews on several sites. Look for recent, detailed reviews from clients whose situation matches yours.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is DJ & Lindsey Real Estate in St. Augustine?
Its website lists an office in St. Augustine along with offices elsewhere in Florida.
Who is Tanya Cosmini?
Tanya Cosmini is the Broker/Owner of Realty ONE Group Elevate, with offices in Jacksonville and St. Augustine, and holds the CLHMS, ABR and MRP designations.
Can I interview more than one agent?
Yes, and you should. Ask each the same questions and compare the answers.
How do I get started with Tanya?
Call or text (904) 929-7643 or use the form below.
Interview Tanya Before You Decide
Tell Tanya what you want to buy or sell and ask her anything. There is no pressure and no obligation.
Explore more: best listing agent in St. Augustine guide, first-time home buyer guide and St. Augustine communities.
Information is general and believed reliable but not guaranteed. Company-reported figures change and are not independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Talk With Tanya
Tell Tanya about your plans and timing.
How Can We Help You?
We would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and we will get in touch with you shortly.
Our Family of Companies
- Realty ONE Group Elevate, a full-service real estate brokerage with offices in Jacksonville and St. Augustine
- Title Company of Florida, title insurance, escrow, and closings statewide, with a $299 settlement fee for veterans, active duty military and first responders
- Rental Property Partners, property management in Jacksonville, St. Augustine, and Ponte Vedra
Affiliated business disclosure: Realty ONE Group Elevate is owned by Tanya Cosmini. Title Company of Florida is owned by her husband, Sam Gorniak, and Rental Property Partners is owned within the same family. Because of these family relationships, the owners may benefit when you use more than one of these companies. You are not required to use any of them and are free to choose other providers.